I am a different person now, then when I was six years old and I am different from when I was eighteen. The me aged eighteen can be said to be 'dead' since it doesn't really exist any more.
I've also often found this dilemma intriguing. What is it they say? The body completely replaces every cell every seven to ten years or something? If that's true then I have been completely replaced some four to five times since birth.
So the thing I am wondering here Modulous, is if you are going to set up a discussion where we are conjecturing "what if" eternal life is true, then why do you still require it to strictly adhere to your conception of reality? I mean this is kind of like saying "what if" Oompaloompas really do work in Wonka's Chocolate factory, then how come he doesn't have to provide health insurance like every other business owner?
Do you see the problem? If you are going to take that step and allow (for the sake of argument) that Oompaloompas exist at all, then you have to go with the full story which says they also never get sick and they also work for nothing.
Likewise if you are going to allow for the sake of argument that there is a God, heaven, and eternal life to be had, then you have to spring for the full package which also states that you have a soul. And though your body has changed since you were 18, and is not the same body, your soul though hopefully wiser and more mature, is and always will be the real you. That part of you has the ability to expand infinitely in understanding and knowledge, however it is not replicating itself. Therefore according to Christian theology, you do not ever become something entirely different from the person you are now, you merely expand upon that person.
the concept of eternal life whichever way it is dressed up fills me with either horror or non-caring.
Think of the love you feel for the person on earth to whom you are the closest. The one person in your life who gives you the greatest joy and meaning to life. Now imagine feeling that relationship grow stronger day by day forever and ever. You never become board and you keep discovering new and fascinating things about that person every day. Now imagine that feeling with someone who is an infinite creator who you could literally spend eternity discovering the depths of His
No webpage found at provided URL: love and grace.
Now imagine an eternity separated from that love. An eternity that you chose by squandering away every chance that you were given to freely receive it.