You schoolastically saturated scholars of secularistic stuff need to be deprogrammed and apprised of the reality of the supernatural.
That's the problem, Buz. The supernatural just doesn't exist. It can't, by definition. On the one hand, if it's something that can affect reality, then it's not supernatural, it's natural. On the other, if it's superior to nature and can't affect it, then there's no reason to suppose it exists.
This is such an obvious paradox about the supernatural that I'm surprised that somebody as old as you hasn't picked up on it.