Although Phatboy did a pretty good job of reading my mind on a few points, I'll explain better what I said.
(a) God cannot be directly measured (in contrast to light)
I was not trying to measure God in this post. This was only to explain my point because I couldn't properly define what light was. To make my point that it was something, I put qualifiers in. Perhaps, this only shows my scientific knowledge that I've never claimed to have....
(b) You attribute the property good to god (for which you have no prove and given some of the contents of the bible, I'm sure some would claim that this is not so, but anyways...).
In the context of the thread, it did not need me to prove God was good. I believe it was an assumed because of the statement phatboy made about God creating the knowledge of good and evil, not evil itself. Besides, if God was evil or even amoral, the answer would be self-evident.
Now you say that by measuring "good", we can deduce God's existence? That's like saying, by knowing that light exerts a pressure (albeit small) on matter it interacts with, we can deduce the presence of light from the observation of pressure?
Where in the world did I say anything about measuring good? This post was not about scientifically finding God, but about where evil came from.....
(c) You keep forgetting about omni-presence (so there's no place where he isn't) and omnipotence... Never mind that he's the creator of everything...
Yeah, he knew it was going to happen, he was there, but perhaps that discussion better stay in the free will thread....
I said it was an analogy and it broke down at some points, but your reading far more into it then I ever intended to be there.