GS writes:
X + Y > X
Of course this only counts for an external independent all powerful God, a God that is an intrinsic part of everything or is not all powerful can not be tackled in this manner - polytheists and pagans etc will not fall to this logic but I am very curious to see how monotheists handle it.
I expect monotheists will proclaim that their god is in some sense an intrinsic part of everything. Even if in practise that "intrinsic part of everything" amounts to little more than having provided the 'energy' that sparked creation and which is thus contained in everything.
Or something like that......
In short I don't think monotheists are going to consider your 'proof' particulalrly relevant or challenging to their notion of god.
™ Version 4.2