ummm. . .
If He is all-powerful then He can offer freewill to His creation. How does that make Him culpable? Are your parents at fault when you do wrong because, technically, they made you?
are you suggesting parents are all--powerful? Or all-knowing? or something that they're not? your analogy is useless.
Here's the problem.
God created everything. God is all-knowing (from what I hear). He knows what will happen. If you get hurt, maimed, or killed, God knew this would happen. In our law system, that's implied consent. If you don't stop a murder that you know will help (or at least make some sort of attempt at such), you are also culpable. And it makes sense. (which I can add on to, should someone desire to see the reason)
So if God knew the Rock would fall, and he did nothing to help prevent injury, he is partially culpable.
Or, he is totally culpable, because if he created everything, he created that rock, he created the man who got hurt, and he created the land the rock was sitting on that led to the eventual injury. In a way, he created the event. Then he is totally culpable.
I think (though could be quite wrong) that this is what causes many people to question just what it is God is trying to do. And it causes many of those questioners to lose their faith.
Want to help give back to the world community? Did you know that your computer can help? Join the newest TeamEvC
Climate Modelling to help improve climate predictions for a better tomorrow.