Film is not to tell stories !!!! - you are just trying to wind me up?
Not trying to wind you up and I'm not saying that film has no business telling stories. Actually, I think that because of the way film uses juxtaposition and the way the human mind works, it can't
help but tell stories. But is plot, or narrative, the most important thing about film? To my mind, not really. I've seen Bunel films that have stories even though I know the director had no narrative intent in making the film. I've seen films that I loved even though, honestly, I felt the story was trite.
My post was to try and emphasise the intellectualisation of film and it's detrimental effect on pure entertainment.
Again, I don't have any problem reconciling intellectualization with entertainment. I suppose the question here is, what do you mean by pure entertainment? I find the Ingmar Bergman films I've seen to be purely entertaining. I find them intellectually, emotionally, and technically engaging. Bergman is a darling of the art house. Is he guilty of adding to the detriment of pure entertainment?
None of these guys had any agenda to pitch, any angle or any hidden message.
Hitchcock did have a message to pitch, an angle, and a hidden message. That's what makes his films so good. He may have been personally unaware of it, but if you watch a succession of his movies, it's pretty clear that certain concepts interested him. Many of his films are based on the same themes or use similar techniques to get at character. Sure, he worked in a less abstract, more representative filmic language than, say, Bergman, but his obsession with the innocent man on the run isn't much different than Bergman's obsession with dopplegangers.
Anyway, back to my point: I don't think story should be the primary purpose in making a film any more than I think novels should be the primary purpose when one sits down to write something. I mean, what about poems?
And just to keep this more on topic: I just watched a film called
Rififi. It's a great French heist movie from the 50s with one of the best robbery sequences I've ever seen.
"In Heaven, everything is fine."
The Lady in the Radiator
Eraserhead
One Movie a Day/Week/Whenever