May, 2005, Posts of the Month

Name: Mr. Ex Nihilo
Forum: Is It Science?
Thread: Evolution: Science, Pseudo-Science, or Both?
Post #: 169Name: NosyNed
Forum: Is It Science?
Thread: Evolution: Science, Pseudo-Science, or Both?
Post #: 170Ned subtitles his message "Facts and philosophies", which seems to be a good 3 word description of what they're covering.I haven't been following this topic very closely, but I suspect there's also some good stuff upthread.Moose

Name: Percy
Forum: Geology and the Great Flood
Thread: Flood not the Cause of the Grand Canyon -- Not a Biased Opinion
Post #: 133Name: roxrkool
Forum: Geology and the Great Flood
Thread: Flood not the Cause of the Grand Canyon -- Not a Biased Opinion
Post #: 134Both are replies to the same message (posted 3 minutes apart) and are thus somewhat redundant, but both have much good content. Percy's is perhaps more readable, especially to the non-geologist; roxrkool gets more technical.Moose

Name: peaceharris
Forum: Geology and the Great Flood
Thread: Flood not the Cause of the Grand Canyon -- Not a Biased Opinion
Post #: Topic wide contributionspeaceharris has made a considerable effort to argue some sort of creationist perspective of the Earth's geology. He has tried his best to "sweat the details", probably significantly beyond any other creationist effort I have ever witnessed.He took on an impossible task, and failed miserably at putting up a coherent alternative to the mainstream geologic thought. But was a much better effort really possible? I don't think so. He was doomed from the start.This situation might call for a topic of its own. The "Posts of the Month" forum is not the place to discuss such further.Moose {Edited to add link to topic.}Added by 2nd edit: There has been some discussion of peaceharris's efforts at the "General discussion of moderation procedures: The Sequel" topic, starting at message 25. Admin's response is at message 27.This message has been edited by minnemooseus, 05-26-2005 05:38 PMThis message has been edited by minnemooseus, 05-28-2005 01:10 PM