I would bet my life savings on the fact that you live in a predominantly Christian countrty.
I would bet my house on the fact that you live in a predominantly Christian community.
I would bet my socks and shoes that you come from a Christian family upbringing.
Given that the response to your storming the gates of heaven is completely and indisputably subjective it comes as no suprise to hear that it was exactly as your upbringing and social indoctrination would decree it to be.
Why did your prayers get answered by Jesus and not Mohammed?
Would a Moslem's prayers have been answered differently?