Schraf, Rand:
I see how these couple of posts are on the current topic. But they teeter on the edge of falling far from it.
Please wrap this bit quickly or take it elsewhere.
I could suggest this approach:
Schraf, you can agree with Rand that God is totally unknowable and that we can have no clue what is good and evil from our inability to know.
The fact that the Bible has a commandment about "baring false witness" can be ignored if you can allow someone to be mislead by simple setting a trap. If God is the source of right and wrong we learn by his use of such traps that it is ok.
So maybe we have been fooled but it is ok to fool someone cause God does it.