I've also never really felt the force of the AP. What are we supposed to get from it?
I take it that those who put forth the argument would say it implies a there is a supernatural being who created the universe for us; but can't we push the question back further?
What are the chances that there would exist a supernatural being which had the ability and desire to create a universe that was fine-tuned for humanity's existence? Out of all the possible characteristics God could have had, it turns out they are all not only compatible, but "fine-tuned," for
our existence.
Are we to conclude that God exists for our existence? Does everything that exists exist for us?