Straggler writes:
Good choices IMHO (when jar can be arsed - which is less and less often these days).
But would you care to elaborate on your choices? Why those and not others?
jar has encouraged me to ask questions and is a stickler at framing issues. His only drawback is that he often stalls discussions by insisting on redefining terms at the expense of allowing a topic originator to frame their own issue.
Ringo is flat out humorous. He is always willing to offer an insightful alternative.
Modulous is, as you say, intelligent and seems well balanced between faith and reason. Even though a self proclaimed atheist, Mod tolerates the faith of others, as long as they themselves are tolerable.