That was my point. That you could comment to summon an expert. You could also comment to point out dogpiling, but perhaps, comments themselves could provide an outlet to dogpiling that wouldn't impact threads and poster to the same extent.
For instance, some comments could be hardcoded. If fallacies are hardcoded, then those comments work more like votes then post.
>>12 people view this post as containing a strawman fallacy.
That won't reduce dog piling, it will increase it.
I've seen it over at Topix when they instituted flags for "funny" or "lemon" or whatever.
Creationist one posts this:
"Jesus made the dinosaurs"
Educated person responds:
"That doesn't make any sense, even within the narrow context of your religious belief."
Then 47 Creationists mark the response as "lemon".
Whether or not whatever is being posted is a strawman, you'll see people marking it strawman. Then you have admins trying to go back and correct labels. Then you have people arguing with admins about why it's not a strawman, or why it is a strawman.
Endless.
Edited by Adminnemooseus, : Fix *** thingy in quote box.