Good answers.
I guess the problem I am having is how do they make these monocultures, or more specifically how do they guarantee that the founding bacterium used is non-resistant. How can they find that out without killing it?
I have been challenged on this and while I can find methods online which show mutation is random, or methods that show bacterial resistance is not caused by the poison itself, but I cannot find any method that convincingly rules out the resistant variant already being present at the beginning of the experiment. I have just taken it as a given. You are right it must be true, but how do I convince someone of this?
The only method I can think of that would seal it would be to take a large number of bacteria and allow them to found seperate large colonies and then poison them. If resistance is caused by mutation you would expect quite a lot of the colonies to have mutated resistant survivors. If instead resistance cannot be aquired by mutation you would expect only a few of the colonies to have resistant survivors. But this is hardly a nice method of determining it. Surely there must be a better way. Please tell me if you know a way.