|
Register | Sign In |
|
QuickSearch
EvC Forum active members: 65 (9164 total) |
| |
ChatGPT | |
Total: 916,909 Year: 4,166/9,624 Month: 1,037/974 Week: 364/286 Day: 7/13 Hour: 2/2 |
Thread ▼ Details |
|
Thread Info
|
|
|
Author | Topic: The evolution of religion? | |||||||||||||||||||||||
anastasia Member (Idle past 5982 days) Posts: 1857 From: Bucks County, PA Joined: |
RAZD writes: Another thing to consider in formalized religion is cult indoctrination techniques. Remember once the initial formulation of the religion has passed the dogma\tradition\ceremonial aspects of the religion are about crowd control by those who want to remain leaders. Would you say that doctrine is part of the initial formation of the newly initiated? Tradition and ceremonial custom are not things designated by leaders, but by the body of the church, the members, and their overall culture. Dogma is not crowd control, it is a belief that is considered non essential or insupportable, and often springs from the crowd themselves.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||
bluegenes Member (Idle past 2507 days) Posts: 3119 From: U.K. Joined: |
petrophysics writes: Let's take something simple like ghosts. Disembodied spiritual beings are today and have been in the past seen by all cultures. Now even though atheists and fundamental christians share the belief that ghosts don't exist, that doesn't make it so. Also people see them, so they must be explained. In my poverty stricken youth, I shared a house in London with some other people, including a guy who would regularly see ghosts in the house. He would also hear voices, and thought that he was telepathic, and could read other people's minds. Sometimes he believed he had a job, and would tell me about it with complete sincerity and in detail, although he was actually unemployed and probably unemployable. He was suffering from severe schizophrenia. His was an extreme case, but I doubt if there's any such thing as the perfect, faultless brain. Most people will probably never "see" a ghost, some might see one, and some might see several, but the less you see the better, because would you really want to end up like my housemate, seeing ghosts all the time and with a brain that just could not be trusted?
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||
RAZD Member (Idle past 1435 days) Posts: 20714 From: the other end of the sidewalk Joined: |
You might be interested in the link drawn in this article
Political and Social Science between schizophrenia and religion quote: The ancients also had lots of stories of seers ... usually holed up and being kept. There is also this articlePage not found - quote: Which leads to the interesting question of whether there is a "religion gene" .... and what to do about it (versus, say, a "homosexual gene" ... ) Enjoy. compare Fiocruz Genome and fight Muscular Dystrophy with Team EvC! (click) we are limited in our ability to understand by our ability to understand RebelAAmericanOZen[Deist ... to learn ... to think ... to live ... to laugh ... to share.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||
bluegenes Member (Idle past 2507 days) Posts: 3119 From: U.K. Joined: |
Both interesting links, RAZD, and relevant to a lot that comes up on EvC threads.
The suggestion that the seers, prophets and visionaries of all religions, the invententors and perpetuators of religions, may well have been epeleptics and schizophrenics is frequently made, and I suspect that the idea may be as old as religion itself. By this I mean that for every mystic visionary, there would also be the cynics (or realists) around who would dismiss claims like "I'm speaking the word of God" by replying "you're crazy, mate." In fact, the "you're crazy" brigade actually win out in the overwhelming majority of cases, but if the madman is charismatic and not too obviously crazy, and perhaps in the right time and place where there's public dissatisfaction and desire for something new, then a major or minor prophet can be born. This view of things won't be too popular amongst the religious, but there's probably something in it. So is religion madness, a kind of infectious psychological virus? Good idea for a thread, if there's never been one on the subject. Edited by bluegenes, : No reason given.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||
RAZD Member (Idle past 1435 days) Posts: 20714 From: the other end of the sidewalk Joined: |
The suggestion that the seers, prophets and visionaries of all religions, the invententors and perpetuators of religions, may well have been epeleptics and schizophrenics is frequently made, and I suspect that the idea may be as old as religion itself. There is also the issue of the "God-Helmet"Holy visions quote: What "sort" is not discussed.
In fact, the "you're crazy" brigade actually win out in the overwhelming majority of cases, but if the madman is charismatic and not too obviously crazy, and perhaps in the right time and place where there's public dissatisfaction and desire for something new, then a major or minor prophet can be born. And the rules of statistics would say that given sufficient opportunity that this would occur. Of course it is more likely to occur in ignorant\gullible populations versus educated\skeptical ones. Enjoy. compare Fiocruz Genome and fight Muscular Dystrophy with Team EvC! (click) we are limited in our ability to understand by our ability to understand RebelAAmericanOZen[Deist ... to learn ... to think ... to live ... to laugh ... to share.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||
numnuts Junior Member (Idle past 6120 days) Posts: 19 Joined: |
Could it be that lack of explanation for natural phenomenon such as weather, life/death, sunrise, etc is reason enough for most beliefs in God? Religious doctrine would seem to come later. The need to establish law within hominid groups could also be a good use for God(s) once they exist. Did the belief start long ago before hominids populated the entire Earth or did it evolve on seperate occasions in different places for different reasons? It would seem a bit of a stretch for it to evolve much later when so many pockets of isolated hominids stretched the Earth. God and religion is so widely spread that one would assume it is a very very old idea without doing any research.
I think therefore I am...busy
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||
New Cat's Eye Inactive Member |
Did the belief start long ago before hominids populated the entire Earth or did it evolve on seperate occasions in different places for different reasons? IIRC, there is evidence that Neandertals buried thier dead, implying religious belief. And since they are not a direct ancestor, that shows that religion did evolve on seperate occasions. Therefore, god must exist (just kidding).
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||
ringo Member (Idle past 441 days) Posts: 20940 From: frozen wasteland Joined: |
Catholic Scientist writes: IIRC, there is evidence that Neandertals buried thier dead, implying religious belief. Or implying that they didn't want dead granny lying around the cave, attracting rats. Help scientific research in your spare time. No cost. No obligation. Join the World Community Grid with Team EvC
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||
New Cat's Eye Inactive Member |
Catholic Scientist writes:
Or implying that they didn't want dead granny lying around the cave, attracting rats. IIRC, there is evidence that Neandertals buried thier dead, implying religious belief. Well you wouldn't have to bury it for that and, IIRC, they were buried with ornaments n'stuff, like in a ceremony.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||
ringo Member (Idle past 441 days) Posts: 20940 From: frozen wasteland Joined: |
Catholic Scientist writes: Well you wouldn't have to bury it for that.... What other method for disposal of the dead would you recommend? Maybe burial of the dead just coincides with living at a fixed location, where various kinds of sanitation become desirable.
... IIRC, they were buried with ornaments n'stuff, like in a ceremony. How does the enjoyment of ceremony and ritual imply religious belief? Help scientific research in your spare time. No cost. No obligation. Join the World Community Grid with Team EvC
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||
New Cat's Eye Inactive Member |
What other method for disposal of the dead would you recommend? Burn it. Or throw it in the bog. Or eat it (if recently dead). Or let another animal eat it. You can't think of any?
Maybe burial of the dead just coincides with living at a fixed location, where various kinds of sanitation become desirable. Maybe
How does the enjoyment of ceremony and ritual imply religious belief? I think the ceremony and ritual, whether enjoyed or not, imply religious belief. Without the religious belief, its just a bunch of unnecessary crap, well even with the religious belief it is a bunch of unnecessary crap but not to the poeple doing the rituals. There is a reason for the ritual. Most likely, it is religious belief but it could be something else. Just for the fun of it? Is that what your saying? Do you honestly think that the Neandertals had no religious beliefs? Why would they bury stuff with a dead body?
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||
ringo Member (Idle past 441 days) Posts: 20940 From: frozen wasteland Joined: |
Catholic Scientist writes: Burn it. Or throw it in the bog. Or eat it (if recently dead). Or let another animal eat it. You can't think of any? Do we know for sure that Neanderthals didn't burn some of their dead or throw some of them in the bog? Do we eat our dead pets? Or let other animals eat them? Do atheists bury their dead pets?
Do you honestly think that the Neandertals had no religious beliefs? I honestly think we don't know for sure. There's only a hint that maybe they had religious beliefs. Why would we assume that they did?
Why would they bury stuff with a dead body? Why not? Help scientific research in your spare time. No cost. No obligation. Join the World Community Grid with Team EvC
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||
New Cat's Eye Inactive Member |
Do we know for sure that Neanderthals didn't burn some of their dead or throw some of them in the bog? It doesn't matter if they did. They could burn a hundred bodies and then bury one with religious ritual and that would suffice to say that the Neandertals had religious beliefs.
I honestly think we don't know for sure. There's only a hint that maybe they had religious beliefs. Why would we assume that they did? Of course we don't know for sure, but as you say, there is evidence that they might have. We might assume that they did for a premise in an argument about the evolution of religion. But aside from that and just looking at the evidence, it looks like they did have religious beliefs, IIRC.
Why would they bury stuff with a dead body? Why not?
Its unneccessary and there's better ways to use things than throwing them away. Your turn. Why would they?
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||
RAZD Member (Idle past 1435 days) Posts: 20714 From: the other end of the sidewalk Joined: |
Do we know for sure that Neanderthals didn't burn some of their dead ... Would this not be evidence of some form of treatment of the dead? Ritual is ritual, and there is evidence of cremation also being used by those that built stonehenge as part of their rituals. The only thing that would not be ritualistic would be leaving the body where it died, untouched. It doesn't have to deal with belief in gods, it can be spirits, especially of the dead or of ancestors (as occurs in many societies). Enjoy. compare Fiocruz Genome and fight Muscular Dystrophy with Team EvC! (click) we are limited in our ability to understand by our ability to understand RebelAAmericanOZen[Deist ... to learn ... to think ... to live ... to laugh ... to share.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||
ringo Member (Idle past 441 days) Posts: 20940 From: frozen wasteland Joined: |
Catholic Scientist writes: They could burn a hundred bodies and then bury one with religious ritual and that would suffice to say that the Neandertals had religious beliefs. If burial with "religious ritual" was a teeny-tiny minority practise, how would it say anything about the evolution of religion?
Its unneccessary and there's better ways to use things than throwing them away. Your turn. Why would they? Mental illness. Help scientific research in your spare time. No cost. No obligation. Join the World Community Grid with Team EvC
|
|
|
Do Nothing Button
Copyright 2001-2023 by EvC Forum, All Rights Reserved
Version 4.2
Innovative software from Qwixotic © 2024