""Everything was created at the same time" is not a fair summary."
Very well. Allow me to be more specific, then. The bible says birds and sea creatures existed BEFORE "wild beasts, livestock, and reptiles" when, the Law of Superposition (among other things) prove that birds are DESCENDED FROM reptiles. Hence birds coming before reptiles is an impossibility. Then again, the bible says that bats are birds too, so I suppose you can't expect any sort of consistancy or accuracy compared to what we know today.
"no creationist thinks that Augustus and I are a direct result of the six-day creation"
Which doesn't say much for an all-knowing god, does it?
"the Bible does not state nor imply that we were both created at the same time"
Nor do I, what's your point?
"the law of superposition was proposed by a creationist"
Neat. Again, what's your point? The big bang was also proposed by a creationist. Darwin himself was studying to become a member of the clergy (and set out on his famous voyage to discover "the centers of creation").
The beliefs of a person (religious or otherwise) are independent of their scientific discoveries. Isaac Newton believed that certain metals had magical powers. Does that reflect the validity of the law of gravitation? The laws of motion?
All religions are based on faith. If faith can lead to false belief, then what is the value of faith?