quote:
I was anxious to know whether you acknowledge your fallacious assertions by misquoting off target Qur'aanic verses to deduce assumptions derived using Biblical Yardstick. Also the topic and/or subject matter was neither well defined not agreed upon (Validity of differing eyewitness accounts in religious texts)
My apologies if I misquoted those sections of the Koran. In error, I assumed that the use of proper names for chapter titles meant that those sections were written by eye witnesses.
quote:
I would also like to know that why do you think that a "Divine Revelation" requires an eyewitness account. Islaam is unlike any other religions, where man makes and/or decides the god of picks the god through a council.
I don't think that Divine revelation requires an eyewitness account - I don't believe in god, so it's a bit of a moot point. The question was intended to determine the status of eyewitness accounts and in those circumstances you have provided some clear points why it is not a valid measurement for the Koran.
I'll skip off the religion rant bit as I don't think it's particularly helpful.
quote:
The assertions made in your post are mute and proves nothing, beside that you have tried to judge the Qur'aan with Biblical yardstick. While the Bible can't even reach the perfectness of the Qur'aan, which is the truly Divine revealed word of Allaah.
I don't really see any assertions in the first post beyond, suggesting those quotes in error. I was posing a question.