Can sense organs like the eye really evolve?

Not yet, anyway. But in a few million years - or perhaps even sooner - the descendants of our peacock will have tails which may be quite different from the current version. 'Transitional' is a relative term, in that a feature can only be said to be transitional with the benefit of hindsight.

Hold your horses Granny, I think Al was trying to make the point that a photo is no more trustworthy than people's memory these days, because photos can be edited. I don't think Al was being facetious. Even the seemingly childish remark about the black jacket serves a purpose, I think. If Al could prove he really didn't own a black jacket, that would disqualify the photo as genuine, regardless what he remembered or not.But I agree that the analogy is wearing thin. It's point was to assert that eyes are superior to cameras, and that since cameras are designed by intelligent beings, the more so eyes must be. Flawed logic, but relevant to the discussion.