crashfrog writes:
Why do you think she was an idiot?
For believing the world is going to end on 21 May 2011.
crashfrog writes:
Why couldn't she have been an entirely regular person incited to a harmful, criminal act by another person acting with reckless disregard for human life and public safety?
She is ultimately responsible for her actions. Just because someone tells you to jump off a cliff...you know the rest.
crashfrog writes:
Are you saying that speech can never be a criminal act? What about fraud? What about saying "I'll give you $10,000 to commit murder on my behalf"? Those are both examples of criminalized speech acts. I don't think someone who hears the latter and then goes off and commits murder is an "idiot" who is solely responsible for their actions. Telling someone you'll pay them to commit murder is nothing but a speech act, but it also makes you party to a crime.
The examples you give are of course crimes. Fraud is of course illegal, so is murder for hire. But predicting the end of the world is not.
crashfrog writes:
I believe Camping is party to this crime, as well.
If found so he will be prosecuted. I doubt they will have a case.