I apologize for forgetting about my post in 14.
I understand that we are on the 'same' side regarding creation and evolution. However, I disagree with the interpretation therein.
Formless and void is just as much a reputable exegesis of the text. Therefore, there is no factual basis to your claim of the best scholarship.
In regards to 1:28. There word plenish would have no place in this manner and is not subject to the re- part. Besides, the definition of replenish (from Webster's) is as follows: to fill with persons or animals: stock. to supply fully. to fill with inspiration or power: nourish. The situation that you are trying to use in this situation is similar to the argument between regardless and irregardless. They mean the same thing and are not exclusive.
I have no idea where you get your idea that young earth creationism is a reactionary method to fear. State your case using some sort of fact and let's dialogue about it. But I find it very frustrating that you are trying to make an emotional situation out of this. I have not come to you stating anything as derogatory as you have brought up regarding people who hold this belief. Doctrinally, young earth creationism is very strong. Scientifically, depending on what mechanism you want to evaluate, is also very strong.
I have no idea what your past has taken you through, but having to 'pay penance' for a belief is nonsense. I have differing views from those in the Body and those out, but to allow myself to deal with those people and consider it penance because of something is far from my mindset. I could give a rip if someone has a differing point of view. I shall not be belittled because of it. As a Christian, I find anything other than YEC difficult to swallow, because of the implications to salvation. However, if that is what you feel is correct; then as I said before, knock yourself out. But, please, do not degrade me or my intellect because I do not agree and feel supported in that belief.