Was I calling NWR dishonest or was I simply saying that that certain sentence of his was?
A sentence can be incorrect, but it cannot be dishonest. "Dishonest" is a statement about intentions, so it had to be referring to the intentions of the person who uttered the sentence.
However, I thought your comment was relatively mild, and the tone was not particularly offensive. That's why I suggested that the 1 week suspension seemed excessive.
Compassionate conservatism - bringing you a kinder, gentler torture chamber