Hey Jon,
Top-down approaches never work. Enforced change is neither stable nor effective.
Are speed limits not effective at reducing road tolls? Democracy is a top down appraoch. You vote the guy/lady in, hopefully legitimately, and he makes decisions. Often not the decision he said he/she would make.
And this goes beyond the simply immorality of enslaving people's minds in some quasi democratic dictatorship of forced votes to the simple mechanics of what's effective and what isn't.
Enslaving people minds? Forced votes? quasi democratic dictatorship? what the hell are you talking about?
Forcing people to behave differently simply doesn't work. In the end, all you can do is educate them and give them the tools needed so that hopefully, when the time comes for them to make those important decisions, they will want to make the right ones and not make the right ones simply as a matter of being forced to.
Is this what you think is happening in the USA now? Do you think that the democracy in the USA currently allows people to do the right thing?
Remember this guy?
Though we've been emphasizing voting, people every day make hundreds of decisions far more lasting and important than the decision of who's going to sit in what chair for the next few years. From where they shop to how they live, people's lifestyle choices can have far-reaching impact on the the planet and the critters that inhabit it. Forcing people to change only makes them miserable, and then we lose the whole battle of trying to make the world a happier place.
Do you think that this is reality? Forcing people to change is sometimes a requirement. Would the north have not invaded the south and forced them to abolish slavery because it would make them sad?
Civic duty can only start and end with the individual, because it is the individual who holds the power to change themself.
So when the people who dont give a fuck finally become the majority, where will we be?
I could agree with you, but then we would both be wrong
Butterfly, AKA, mallethead - Dawn Bertot
"Superstitions and nonsense from the past should not prevent us from making progress. If we hold ourselves back, we admit that our fears are more powerful than our abilities." Hunters of Dune Herbert & Anderson
2011 leading candidate for the EvC Forum Don Quixote award