Register | Sign In


Understanding through Discussion


EvC Forum active members: 64 (9164 total)
2 online now:
Newest Member: ChatGPT
Post Volume: Total: 916,901 Year: 4,158/9,624 Month: 1,029/974 Week: 356/286 Day: 12/65 Hour: 0/0


Thread  Details

Email This Thread
Newer Topic | Older Topic
  
Author Topic:   A Modern Day Miracle Man - Establishes the Supernatural Realm
Rahvin
Member
Posts: 4046
Joined: 07-01-2005
Member Rating: 7.6


(1)
Message 37 of 297 (525737)
09-24-2009 12:32 PM
Reply to: Message 1 by Cedre
09-24-2009 5:09 AM


(insert mockery of Cedre here)
This is laughable.
Healing and health-related events
Instantaneous baby deliveries[17],
Child delivery is common in periods of extreme stress or heightened emotion. If you've ever seen a "faith-healing" pastor at work, you'd know this qualifies.
healing of terrible cancerous sores,
Pictures, or it didn't happen.
the deadly HIV/AIDS virus[18],
Fuck you, asshole. Lots of snakeoil salesmen, particularly in Africa, claim to be able to cure AIDS/HIV - that's where we got the whole "rape a virgin for a cure" nonsense, after all.
Show documented cases where multiple people have been diagniosed by a medical professional with HIV/AIDS, and have subsequently been diagnosed by a medical professional with an undetectable viral load and normal T-cell count after no less than one year with no medication.
Here's the quote from the article Wiki refers to:
quote:
These people tested positive for HIV only a few weeks ago. Their medical certificates, clearly giving a positive reading, were a death sentence for most. Today, after returning to local hospitals for tests, they proudly show off their latest medical reading for HIV - it's negative. Paul Akarigbo tested positive four times at four different laboratories. But then he visited TB Joshua.
Paul Akarigbo: "So after that the doctor called me and said, 'Look, you are free.' I went back for the Lagos test at the university hospital with this note. I was confirmed HIV negative."
Weeks ago?! IDIOT! HIV negative?! IDIOT!
That's not the way HIV diagnosis works.
So here's a quote from Wiki on HIV testing:
quote:
Antibody tests
HIV antibody tests are specifically designed for routine diagnostic testing of adults; these tests are inexpensive and extremely accurate.
[edit] Window period
Antibody tests may give false negative (no antibodies were detected despite HIV being present) results during the window period, an interval of three weeks to six months between the time of HIV infection and the production of measurable antibodies to HIV seroconversion.
So, they were tested positive a few weeks ago, and now they don't?
Sounds like they were tested during the window period and received false negatives on their second testing. COme see me in a year.
You're perpetuating a lie that objectively results in countless deaths as gullible fools stop taking their medication because they believe they've been "cured," or stop taking even minimal precautions because they believe a cure is readily available. Moron.
barrenness,
Because infertility is always 100% certain, amirite?
and raising from the dead [19]
Bullshit. Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence. This is about as extraordinary as it gets...and your evidence is a wikipedia entry, backed by a fucking news article with absolutely no independent verification - the only person interviewed in teh story, the person who confirmed the man was "dead," is one of the church members!
The facts of the case involve a man who stopped breathing and lost consciousness for an estimated 10 minutes, and remained unconscious for the rest of the day after he started breathing again.
From the lips of the interviewed witness:
quote:
He said his colleagues are surprised when he recounts his story. "People must choose whether they believe in science or in God. I believe it is possible. I saw it with my own eyes and I believe in the Bible," he says.
Only an idiot buys this sort of nonsense.
all through prayer in the name of Jesus Christ are among the reported miraculous activities taking place at SCOAN. In September 2008, it was reported that a man who had been mentally ill for 14 years was restored to sanity and reunited with his family at SCOAN.[20] Spiritual healing at The SCOAN has been mentioned by Time magazine [21][22].
Claims are not evidence, Cedre.
Michael Jackson Prophecy
TB Joshua is also said to have prophesied the death of the iconic pop legend, Michael Jackson, [37] [38][39] [40] [41] personally sending a message of warning through his brother Marlon Jackson, who later visited the church during a trip to Nigeria after his brother's death [42] [43].T. B. Joshua - Wikipedia
"Said to have prophesied?"
Well, gee. I'm "said to have prophesied" the exact value of teh stock market every day for the past decade back when I was in elementary school.
I'm "said to have prophesied" 9/11.
I'm "said to have prophesied" that Cedre would make one of the most laughably stupid series of assertions I have ever seen.
See how easy that is?
Look, I could keep going, but I don't need to. This isn't the presentation of evidence - you're just pulling a Gish Gallop, trying to bury us in numerous unsupported assertions so that you can claim victory when we don't refute them all.
The fact is, you've presented a bunch of claims, with no evidence. You seem incapable of distinguishing the two.
You're just enabling another faith-healing fraud as he gives unfounded hope to people who are actually suffering. Numerous studies have been done on faith healing, and they've always shown that, while people may receive a temporary benefit (short-term pain relief, etc), and many people believe they;ve been cured, the symptoms (when they actually existed in teh first place) return later. In some cases, people have died believing that their cancer was cured because they stopped going to the doctor.
As far as I'm concerned, perpetuating this sort of fraud without real evidence, independently verified (and no, a news reporter is not independent verification - they just repeat the story they're told) makes you an accessory to murder. And a gullible fool.

This message is a reply to:
 Message 1 by Cedre, posted 09-24-2009 5:09 AM Cedre has replied

Replies to this message:
 Message 38 by New Cat's Eye, posted 09-24-2009 12:45 PM Rahvin has not replied
 Message 43 by Cedre, posted 09-24-2009 1:52 PM Rahvin has not replied
 Message 54 by slevesque, posted 09-24-2009 2:41 PM Rahvin has replied
 Message 57 by Theodoric, posted 09-24-2009 3:08 PM Rahvin has not replied
 Message 84 by Admin, posted 09-25-2009 7:46 AM Rahvin has not replied

  
Rahvin
Member
Posts: 4046
Joined: 07-01-2005
Member Rating: 7.6


Message 64 of 297 (525788)
09-24-2009 4:26 PM
Reply to: Message 54 by slevesque
09-24-2009 2:41 PM


Re: (insert mockery of Cedre here)
I don't want to jump into this discussion, but I'll coment a bit on the HIV tests and things.
The window of 3 to 6 months were you test negative is after infection, not detection. In other words, if I catch AIDS tomorrow, there will be this timespan were no test will detect it, yet I will be able to transmit it to other people. This is the very reason why you have the whole questionnaire when you go and give blood, because there tests aren't 100% because of this time period.
But note that as soon as it becomes 'detectable' in you, than you have passed this window and it will always be detectable. It doesn't fluctuate from positive t negative after that. (Or else doing AIDS tests on blood sample during blood donation would be almost useless)
HIV tests typically begin with an antibody test. After an antibody test comes up positive, a followup Western Blot test is typically performed (in the US anyway - I have no idea of the testing methods used elsewhere, particularly in the Third World).
An antibody test will always come up as positive after you've been exposed to the virus. The antibodies don't go away.
The Western Blot test measures viral load. This can come up as "undetectable, which simply means no viral particles were found in teh sample,. This doesn't mean a person has been "cured," but it can be interpreted as a "negative" result.
This is probably what happened - a person tested positive on an antibody test, and came up with an undetectable viral load on the Western Blot. It's not uncommon. Once a person is on medication, it's much more common to test as undetectable.
A person can only really be said to be "cured" of HIV if their viral load is still undetectable after a significant amount of time without drug therapy - obviously, that's rather risky to test. But "a few weeks" is nowhere near long enough to verify that a person is HIV-free, as Cedre's proposed.
The point is that "I tested positive, and now I test negative" is both woefully oversimplified as far as what tests are performed, and completely irrelevant if insufficient time has passed. We don;t even know if the individuals in question were taking medication, the tests done initially and after their supposed "cure," the lab that performed the test...
There's a reason the medical community is not endorsing "Faith healing" as a cure for HIV.
All this is to say that if you are tested positive at an AIDS test, you can't possibly test negative again, you're done, Unless a miracle, or a very very very very improbable event (I remember this guy down in ontario who was cured of AIDS after he had the flu.)
I'd like to see a source for that.
I know that there are some people who have a genetic resistance to HIV and will test positive on an antibody test (showing that they've definitely been exposed), but will never display a detectable viral load, never show a drop in T-cells, and generally will be like someone exposed to any other disease but didn't get sick.
Thanks for that insight slevesque it cleared up a lot. I guess then that these people really were cured of Aids.
Isn't it fun how Cedre doesn't verify, doesn't really read anything, and just takes something that he thinks agrees with his point and then declares victory?

This message is a reply to:
 Message 54 by slevesque, posted 09-24-2009 2:41 PM slevesque has replied

Replies to this message:
 Message 68 by slevesque, posted 09-24-2009 11:46 PM Rahvin has not replied

  
Newer Topic | Older Topic
Jump to:


Copyright 2001-2023 by EvC Forum, All Rights Reserved

™ Version 4.2
Innovative software from Qwixotic © 2024