quote:
Originally posted by gene90:
Plus, for the sake of argument, what if somebody made an experiment out of it and did a statistical analysis of the result? For the sake of argument, what if they found out the prayer made a difference? Wouldn't that eliminate your claim of it being unfalsifiable?
Sorry, I'm coming into this a little bit late BUT...
Does prayer make a difference? That can and has been tested. The most influential of these tests can be read about
here.(long) Of all the studies I've found on prayer, the only ones that pass scientific muster are inconclusive.
Does prayer make a difference? That can be tested and a hypothesis about whether or not prayer works is falsifiable. What can't be falsified is the idea that God answers prayers. More than likely, when you pray for something small to happen and that small thing does in fact happen, the outcome is determined either by chance or by your actions and not God's.
If you want something, why do you have to, "meet God half way?" Have you ever read the book
Where the Red Fern Grows? In the book the main character prays to God for the two red-bone coon hounds that he saw in the paper. He ended up getting the two puppies after two years of hard work and then attributed his gain to God's will. He claimed that God gave him strength to work as hard as he did to get the cash to buy the pups. Isn't it possible that it was merely his
belief in God that gave him the strength? That sounds much more likely to me.
LogicaLunatic
http://www.objectivity.tk