The problem with EVC

You probably missed the joke, not being American. It was a reference to Lake Wobegon

Using logic, as you just described it, requires carefully stating the premises, and then drawing conclusions. Robin often has not been doing that. People have challenged him to clearly state the premises being used, and he has evaded those challenges.Challenging Robin to clearly state his premises is not snobbery. While some such arguments fail due to fallacious logic, the usual problem is the use of a faulty premise. Naturally, people want to be able to question his premises.

I think you are reading that into what is said.It is my impression that you are held in considerable respect. Nevertheless, when you present weak arguments, people point this out to you.Maybe I am merely stating my own view and reading that into what others say. I guess it is hard to know. I see it as a sign of respect that people are willing to take the time to answer your arguments.

At the time, I thought the FSM was a bit silly.Nitpicking satire is even sillier.